Section 101 Alice (Abstract Idea) Appeal Decisions Surge, but Reversal Rate Stays Steady

Abstract idea rejections (mostly Alice-impacted in computer-implemented inventions) are experiencing a surge at the PTAB. We previously reported that August 2018 saw a record number of abstract idea appeals decisions. But the following month shattered this record number of appeals decisions by a large margin. Practitioners have been increasingly appealing abstract idea rejections and it is dramatically showing itself in the final written decisions. The most recent data show that appeals are a more attractive option to overcoming such rejections with still small but not hopeless odds.

As we previously reported, August 2018 saw a record number of reversals (30) based in part from the equally record number of total abstract idea decisions that month (207). The following month of September saw these records shattered at the PTAB. Even with a modest total increase in the total number of decisions (771 to 840, or about a 9% increase), the number of abstract idea decisions for September increased to 257, a 24% increase.

abstractideanumbers

That surge in abstract idea decisions resulted in a record-setting 37 reversals. So while the total number of abstract idea reversals was impressive, the actual reverse rate (14.4%) stayed relatively level, on par with previous months and far lower than other grounds of rejection. As we reported, June and July saw a Berkheimer bump above the 16% reverse rate.

While the reversal rates of recent August and September months are lower than June and July, considering the substantial number of appeals with these rejections, it appears that practitioners are looking to the PTAB for relief. That is, rather than abandoning cases with determined Examiners standing by their Section 101 rejections, practitioners are increasingly using less-trodden techniques (appeals) with overcoming these rejections. After all, some practitioners view appeals as a last resort, especially in some technology sectors, due to the substantial time commitment to reach a final written decision.

Continue to expect appeal decisions that decide Section 101 rejections to increase, as the unpredictability at the USPTO plays out. Also, check out the new Research user interface that allows you to select the specific issues and subissues that you are interested in.

research2

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: